When approached as the first half of a typical three-act story, «Dune: Part One» makes a lot more sense. It really only brings the audience through the first act and a half of the tale. The majority of the film serves as Act One (the setup). There is a lot of worldbuilding, which is fun in Frank Herbert’s fictional world of Arrakis. A slew of characters are introduced, and some — like Oscar Isaac’s Duke Leto Atreides — are even bumped off early.
Things progress into Act Two (the midpoint or confrontation) when Harkonnen forces invade Arrakis. The heroes of House Atriedes are either killed or flee, including Jessica (Rebecca Ferguson) and Paul (Timothée Chalamet), who end up in the desert, captured by the local Fremen. After earning their respect, they are taken in and Paul begins to realize the latent potential of this wild group of native inhabitants of the arid planet … just in time for the story to abruptly end.
When «Part One» ends, the action is just beginning to build momentum, only for it to come to a screeching halt. In Villeneuve’s own words, «The first movie was more meditative and contemplative. We were following a young man discovering a new planet, a new culture.» Now that the stage is set, it’s time to ramp things up.
Robert Pattinson made the right choice by refusing Catherine Hardwicke’s request for him to wear hair extensions because the mop would’ve been more of a problem than what he ended up working with … and what he ended up working with was already a big problem. During a 2009 interview with Entertainment Weekly, Pattinson vented his frustration regarding the integral role his hair played during the filming process. According to him, if even so much as one tousled strand wasn’t perfect, entire shots were scrapped.
«I sound so stupid, but in a lot of ways the hair is 75 percent of my performance,» said Pattinson. «So in the second one I said, ‘Listen, I need to tone down the hair. Let’s make it a little more real, a little bit more … method.’ And then in the third one, I’m doing fight scenes and there’s a strand going down my forehead and they’re like, ‘We need to do it again because no one will recognize you! No one will know who it is!’ I have to look like the poster at all times. Just in case they want to use any clip for the trailer. Any clip at all! There were about five people in different departments who, because of my forelock, ended up in tears.»
Hilariously, Pattinson once admitted to a gross habit on the set of «Twilight.» He told Extra that he rarely washed his hair during the filming process because he didn’t see the point in it. Considering the actor’s penchant for lying during interviews, he could’ve been fibbing, or he could’ve been doing his best to make audiences hate the iconic hairstyle so much that no one would ever expect him to wear it again. Who knows?
Get caught up on the latest technology and startup news from the past week. Here are the most popular stories on GeekWire for the week of Nov. 26, 2023.
Sign up to receive these updates every Sunday in your inbox by subscribing to our GeekWire Weekly email newsletter.
Most popular stories on GeekWire
Nobody dropped the tech industry’s tried and true “fail fast” mantra, but during a tour Wednesday of Amazon’s newly opened Sonic office tower in Bellevue, Wash., the theme was definitely about experimenting, learning and evolving. … Read More
Reporting from Las Vegas … Brilliant marketing move or big waste of money? … Read More
At a company famous for turning doors into desks, it only made sense for Amazon’s cloud division to find its first desktop productivity device in one of its consumer division’s existing streaming media products. … Read More
Annapurna Labs co-founder Nafea Bshara knows semiconductors and appreciates a good red wine. … Read More
The Seattle City Council is closing in on new rules requiring roughly 4,100 existing buildings of more than 20,000 square feet to cut their greenhouse gas emissions to zero by 2050. … Read More
Reporting from Las Vegas … Amazon Web Services CEO Adam Selipsky doubled down on the new era of artificial intelligence with a series of product announcements and thinly veiled but repeated criticism of Microsoft and OpenAI. … Read More
Seattle pet-sitting marketplace Rover announced Wednesday that it has agreed to be acquired by asset manager Blackstone in a deal worth approximately $2.3 billion. … Read More
Three months after rolling out a food truck to launch his sustainable, fast-casual, chicken sandwich joint Mt. … Read More
Will artificial intelligence serve humanity — or will it spawn a new species of conscious digital beings with their own agenda? … Read More
Broadcom, the San Jose, Calif.-based semiconductor and software tech multinational, is laying off 158 workers in Bellevue, Wash., according to a new filing with the Washington state Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) system. … Read More
We hate to say it, but theory or not, if you transported John Doe (Kevin Spacey) out of this miserable metropolis and over to Gotham City, he’d fit right in with the most feared foes of the Dark Knight. Establishing his own rules and leaving cryptic crime scenes for detectives to break apart, Doe displays heinous habits that match the likes of The Riddler, Calendar Man, and Victor Zsaz. Diaries, dedication, and the «logic» to his insanity are something that Batman would undoubtedly be able to wrap his head around. And, if the Caped Crusader was around at the time of the killings, he possibly could have even thwarted them before the film’s heartbreaking finale.
Instead, the theory suggests that Doe’s deeds sparked the rise of extravagant criminals and their activities. The death of Doe led to the birth of Batman’s boldest bad guys, who all came with their own schtick and modus operandi. To quote Mills himself, «Who knows? So many freaks out there doin’ their little evil deeds they don’t wanna do…’The voices made me do it. My dog made me do it. Jodie Foster told me to do it.’» But while the likes of Edward Nygma were taking notes and making sure to get their question marks just right, Doe’s final act led to one of his opponents understandably reeling from loss and into a level of insanity that only the Dark Knight could compete with.
By now, everyone knows that «Pretty Woman,» which came quite early in Roberts’ career, is the movie that established her as a true Hollywood heavyweight. Not only did she win a Golden Globe and score an Academy Award nomination for playing sex worker Vivian Ward — who agrees to spend a few days with businessman Edward Lewis (Richard Gere) and pose as his girlfriend — but thanks to her earnest, winning performance in the movie, she became America’s sweetheart.
After that, Roberts’ career took off. Not only did she end up winning an Oscar ten years after «Pretty Woman» — for her title role as the intrepid real-life lawyer in Erin Brockovich — she became a queen of romantic comedies. She worked with Marshall again on «Runaway Bride». She also headlined modern-day classics like «My Best Friend’s Wedding» and «Notting Hill,» eventually joining ensemble films like the «Ocean’s» franchise while she became one of the biggest movie stars on the planet.
Julia Roberts is a Hollywood mainstay now, appearing in more romantic comedies like «Ticket to Paradise» and headlining the new Netflix film «Leave the World Behind» — and it’s partly thanks to Garry Marshall’s corny jokes, apparently.
Jon Hamm also mentioned what a longtime fan he’s been of franchises like X-Men and Marvel Comics, even as he wondered about landing such a role. «Those decisions get made at such a high level at this point, definitely above my pay grade. I would love to,» he said. «I’ve been a fan of Marvel Comics and comics in general since I was probably single digits. I think there are tons of stories that I’m familiar with, at least, that are still out there to be told.»
As Hamm said, there’s definitely a ton of actors who’d jump at the chance to star in Marvel’s latest action tentpole, but perhaps his enthusiasm for the source material could give him a leg up over the competition. Furthermore, since the «Mad Men» and «Fargo» alum has put in such impressive and varied work over the course of his career, it’s easy to see why he might find himself near the top of the list.
While it may be years before fans finally get to see the actor joining the ranks of the MCU, if ever, the fact that he’s expressed interest in more than one role, along with his passion for the source material, will hopefully see him one day getting his wish.
Toad’s apparent death in «X-Men» is one of the film’s most memorable scenes. During the battle at the Statue of Liberty, Storm uses her lightning abilities to shock Toad and send him flying through the air, with him crashing in the distance far, far away from the fight. The implication is that he’s dead, seeing as he doesn’t reappear beyond that point in the «X-Men» canon. Thus, it’s reasonable to wonder how the character could factor into «Deadpool 3.» In the event he does pop up in the film, there’s a good chance he’ll just be a variant from another timeline.
Assuming Marvel Studios stays within the «X-Men» movie timeline, though, his presence can still work. It’s worth remembering that in «X-Men: Days of Future Past,» Wolverine goes back to 1973 and successfully changes the course of time, preventing the Sentinel-driven apocalypse shown to have occurred in 2023. This results in the likes of Jean Grey (Famke Janssen) and Cyclops (James Marsden) avoiding their previously seen deaths. Perhaps in this new timeline, the Lady Liberty fight either doesn’t go down at all or unfolds differently, resulting in Toad’s survival.
Of all of Fox’s «X-Men» characters to bring in for «Deadpool 3,» Toad is certainly a peculiar choice. We’ll get to see if rumors of his return are indeed true when the film arrives in theaters on July 26, 2024.
As Margot Robbie pointed out, though, it ended well. «I think this is a really great pairing, actually. It’s a perfect double billing, ‘Oppenheimer’ and ‘Barbie,’» she said. «Clearly the world agreed. Thank God. The fact that people were going and being like, ‘Oh, watch Oppenheimer first, then Barbie.’ I was like, ‘See? People like everything.’ People are weird.»
Cillian Murphy seconded that sentiment, replying, «And they don’t like being told what to do. They will decide, and they will generate the interest themselves.» Not only is he right, but Robbie’s next observation was particularly astute: «I think they were also really excited by the filmmakers. People were itching for the next Chris Nolan film and itching for the next Greta Gerwig film.»
Robbie, frankly, is right. Christopher Nolan and Greta Gerwig are two of the most unique and talented directors working today, and the best part about their work is how wildly it diverges. While Gerwig usually tackles coming-of-age stories like «Lady Bird,» Nolan’s projects are notably high-concept, like «Dunkirk,» which used practical effects to their fullest extent. It’s worth noting, though, that both filmmakers have played fast and loose with timelines — Gerwig in «Little Women» and Nolan in «Tenet.» Looks like they’ve got more than a shared release date in common.
Matt Wood, Amazon Web Services VP of Product, shows some of the third-party services that Amazon Connects with in its new Amazon Q artificial intelligence tool for work. (GeekWire Photo / Todd Bishop)
Conference attendees in Las Vegas are accustomed to encountering people standing on the street, aggressively trying to hand them flyers for, well, let’s just say for a variety of different services.
So it was a surprise, and a sign of the times, when someone standing on the Las Vegas Strip handed me a flyer for something else entirely during the Amazon Web Services re:Invent cloud conference this week.
“NEED GPU?” it read, in bold letters.
The promotional materials were from a company touting what it described as the “largest stockpile of GPUs available for the best price” — underscoring the soaring demand and short supply of the graphics processing units instrumental for training artificial intelligence models.
It’s a new world, and of course AI was the big theme inside the longrunning AWS re:Invent conference, as well. The company’s announcements included a new AI assistant for work called Amazon Q.
Before heading back to Seattle, I got a chance to speak with Matt Wood, AWS vice president of product, about the new service and the new era of AI for business.
Several of his comments illustrated the rapid evolution of technology this year:
The rise of generative AI this year: “I have not seen this level of energy and enthusiasm and excitement and engagement from customers probably since the very earliest days of AWS when it was really kicking into high gear. We were thrilled but really having to work hard to keep up with customers’ enthusiasm for building. Very, very similar this year, with generative AI.”
AI and regulated industries: “One of the surprises to me over the past 12 months are the regulated industries. These are industries that potentially don’t have the best reputation for being in the vanguard of technology: insurance, financial services, health care, life sciences, all these sorts of things. But in an ironic twist, all of the regulations that they’ve been working through over the past 20-30 years have been around data privacy, and data governance, and data standards, and structured data quality. They’re all the things you need to have in place to successfully apply your own data to generative AI. … For a very small incremental investment, they can start applying that data with generative AI really, really quickly; really, really easily.”
Changing perspectives on data structures: “I was joking with a customer yesterday, they were saying that they have really, really old data. And a lot of it is structured, but they’ve got this notes field, and it’s just natural language text. And we were joking that, even a year ago, you would have said, ‘I’ve got all this structured data, thank goodness.’ But now you’re like, ‘Oh natural language text, thank goodness, that’s the gold, right?’ So it’s totally changed how you think about the data and where the value is.”
One of the notable aspects of Amazon Q is its ability to connect to business data from a variety of applications, including Microsoft 365, Slack, Salesforce, Dropbox, and Amazon S3. Asked about the execution of these features, Wood explained that the connections are made through APIs, but he also said there’s more cooperation among cloud rivals than people might expect.
“We have good relationships with with a lot of folks that we compete with in other areas. We sell a lot of Windows licenses on EC2 as an example, and through Amazon WorkSpaces,” he said. “So we have we have really good working relationships. The integration as it’s done under the hood is done through APIs, but that is not because we have any animosity towards these things.”
Hear more highlights from my conversation with AWS VP Matt Wood on this week’s GeekWire Podcast. Listen above, or subscribe to GeekWire in Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you listen.
Postscript: On Friday afternoon, the newsletter Platformer reported that some Amazon employees are raising concerns about accuracy and privacy issues involving Amazon Q, which they say have come up in the internal use. Q has been “experiencing severe hallucinations and leaking confidential data,” according to leaked documents, including “the location of AWS data centers, internal discount programs, and unreleased features,” as Platformer reported.
Amazon downplayed the issues and specifically denied some of the claims.
“Some employees are sharing feedback through internal channels and ticketing systems, which is standard practice at Amazon. No security issue was identified as a result of that feedback,” an Amazon spokesperson said in statement to GeekWire. “We appreciate all of the feedback we’ve already received and will continue to tune Q as it transitions from being a product in preview to being generally available.”
The statement added, “Amazon Q has not leaked confidential information.”
In the final segment of this week’s show, we listen back to AWS CEO Adam Selipsky’s thinly veiled jabs at Microsoft and OpenAI during his re:Invent keynote this week. You may notice that one of those clips is of lower quality. That’s because it’s from my own recorder, sitting in the crowd. The reference was removed from the official Amazon recording after the fact.
Update: Amazon got back to me on this. This portion of the keynote isn’t available for on-demand viewing because they don’t have permission/license to display the CNBC content in the on-demand version. In other words, they weren’t intending to pull any punches by not putting the comment online.
Marvel need not have worried so much about «Eternals» suffering from a connection to «The Inhumans» because Chloé Zhao’s film underperformed at the box office all on its own. Shortly after its release, Forbes accused «Eternals» of being the only MCU project to not bill itself as anything other than a superhero film. In comparison, «Captain America: The Winter Soldier» was marketed to audiences as a spy thriller that just happened to feature superheroes. Forbes then claimed that Marvel’s success is bolstered by its films living in other genres and that, without one, «Eternals» proved itself generic.
The Direct offered a comprehensive list of suggested causes, such as a two-dimensional villain, an absence of chemistry between romantic leads Sersi (Gemma Chan) and Ikaris (Richard Madden), an excessive runtime, and an even more excessive band of new characters with commensurate expositional drag. «Eternals» also suffered review bombing prior to its release.
«Eternals» might not have been allowed to appear correlated with «The Inhumans» but Marvel demanded no such barrier when «Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness» went into development. The 2022 film features an extended cameo for Black Bolt (Anson Mount) as an active member of the Illuminati, making «The Inhumans» one of the few ABC properties to tie back into the larger MCU, if only briefly.
While Hugh Jackman is still working to maintain his Wolverine transformation as «Deadpool 3» resumes production, the actor has been prepping for the role for a decent bit of time. In fact, there was previously an incident in which his work to regain Wolverine’s physique interfered with another important role.
During an appearance on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, Jackman revealed that part of his bulk-up regimen necessitated him eating anywhere from 4,500 to 6,000 calories a day. Unfortunately, the performer’s dietary change happened to coincide with his stint as Harold Hill in the Broadway play «The Music Man,» leading to some awkward wardrobe malfunctions. «I’m sorry for the audiences in the front row, I’m sorry for my cast, I’m sorry for my wife, it was not pretty,» Jackman said. «I split my pants three times.»
With work continuing on «Deadpool 3» in order to make its premiere date of July 26, 2024, it seems that Jackman’s other roles will have to account for his Wolverine physique for just a little while longer.
The casting news for «Superman: Legacy» kicked off in June 2023 when DC Studios found its Clark Kent and Lois Lane in David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan. Since then, writer-director James Gunn cast his frequent film collaborator Nathan Fillion as Green Lantern and «Barry» star Anthony Carrigan as Metamorpho. «The Righteous Gemstones» star Skyler Gisnodo has also joined the cast as Lane’s Daily Planet sidekick, Jimmy Olsen. In addition, Gunn eyed Bradley Cooper to play Superman’s nemesis, Lex Luthor, before Nicholas Hoult was cast as the key DC supervillain.
If Kurt Russell gets the call to play Jor-El, he will have two big pairs of cinematic shoes to fill. In addition to Marlon Brando embodying the role in «Superman: The Movie,» Russell Crowe played Jor-El in Zack Snyder’s 2013 blockbuster, «Man of Steel,» which stars Henry Cavill in the title role.
Claiming he knows nothing of the rumors of his potential casting as Jor-El for «Superman: Legacy,» Russell did note for Comic Book how he’d like to see more of the character’s back story. On top of that, Russell appeared excited about the notion of working with Gunn again. «You know what — we don’t know a lot about Jor-El. Maybe there’s a version… I never heard this, so I don’t know,» Russell said while addressing the Jor-El rumor. «James Gunn was a blast to work with, though, so you never know.»
«Superman: Legacy» is scheduled for a July 11, 2025, release.
In the report, Variety added that Paltrow hasn’t always been this absent-minded or disinterested about her MCU tenure. On the contrary, when she started out in «Iron Man,» she enjoyed the almost Indie feel of it all. «They said it’s going to feel like doing an indie film,» she explained. «We’re gonna have fun and you don’t have to be in too much of the action part anyway. So I thought, Oh, okay. And we had such a good time. We improvised almost every scene of that movie. We would write it in the morning in Jon’s trailer, and it was like doing [an indie] film.»
Paltrow may have enjoyed her first foray as Pepper Potts, but it wasn’t long before the shine wore off. The skyrocketing popularity of the films made them major productions, and that took much of the fun out of the creative process. At this point, there’s only one thing that could purportedly get her back into character: Robert Downey Jr.
In an interview with Entertainment Tonight, Paltrow joked, «But, I guess Robert Downey Jr. could probably always get me back. You know, to some degree.» The only issue with that plan? In yet another interview, MCU boss Kevin Feige made it clear that they would never bring RDJ’s Tony Stark back to avoid magically undoing his impeccable send-off in «Avengers: Endgame.» It looks like Paltrow’s role in the MCU is over for the foreseeable future, which should leave her plenty of time to eventually catch up on all of the Marvel movies she’s missed — in theory, anyway.
A man has gone viral for a second time after the moment he quit with the help of a marching band resurfaced online.
Joey DeFrancesco decided to skip the usual email of resignation route and instead enlisted his marching band to announce his departure from his unhappy job.
DeFrancesco documented the moment he told his boss “I quit” and uploaded it to YouTube in 2011. Now, in 2023, the internet is doing what the internet does and recirculating on TikTok once more.
Quitting the job with the help of a marching band
It’s unconventional, but DeFrancesco gained huge online fame when he made the decision to quit via marching band. “They treat us like s**t,” he told the camera at the start of the video. “I’m going to go and quit right now with the help of my bandmates.”
With his fellow members of What Cheer? Brigade, DeFrancesco entered the hotel through the side entrance. After finding the boss, he told them to leave. DeFrancesco responds by handing him his resignation letter and telling him “I quit.”
The band instantly began, like a movie soundtrack, and played loudly as DeFranco walked away smiling widely.
In 2011, the epic moment went hugely viral and currently has 9 million views on YouTube – that was a lot at the time.
Image by Getty Images/ krisanapong detraphiphat
The back story behind the video
DeFrancesco told HuffPost at the time that issues between workers and management had been a “big drawn-out war” and that he wanted to get “one last shot at them.”
“I hated them and they hated me,” he told the outlet.
The resignation came after a long fight from workers to unionize. Workers voted to join a union just over a year before the video, which resulted in some benefits but also strained relations with management.
Scheduling issues were a huge part of the decision, with workers telling media they were made to work late shifts only to return to open just a few hours later. DeFrancesco told HuffPost his loss of shifts after unionizing was one of the main reasons he decided to quit.
TikTok users have been loving the epic resignation
After being shared to TikTok by popular meme video account @laughhard__ on October 15, the video was seen by millions more people. As it stands, the TikTok post has 930k likes.
“Legend says the boss still hears the band’s music in the background,” joked one user.
“The level of petty I aspire to be,” added another.
“You must include this on your resume,” reads one comment. “It shows creativity, initiative and dedication to seeing a project through to the end. Bravo.”
SpaceX’s Falcon 9 rocket launches a set of Starlink satellites on Nov. 27. Amazon has struck a deal to use Falcon 9 rockets for some of its Project Kuiper satellites as well. (SpaceX Photo)
Amazon’s Project Kuiper may be a competitor for SpaceX’s Starlink satellite broadband network, but business is business: Amazon says it has signed a contract for three launches of Project Kuiper satellites on SpaceX’s Falcon 9 rocket, supplementing scores of launches reserved on bigger rockets that haven’t yet made their debut.
“The additional launches with SpaceX offer even more capacity to support our deployment schedule,” Amazon said today in a news release. Amazon did not provide information about the potential timing of the launches, or their cost.
Like Starlink, Project Kuiper is designed to open up broadband internet access to tens of millions of people around the world who are underserved. SpaceX has a big head start in the market, with thousands of satellites already in orbit and more than 2 million subscribers for Starlink’s service.
Amazon, in contrast, had its first two prototype satellites sent into orbit on a United Launch Alliance Atlas V rocket just this October. A couple of weeks ago, Amazon reported that the satellites passed a monthlong series of tests, opening the way for satellites to be mass-produced at a factory in Kirkland, Wash. (For what it’s worth, SpaceX’s satellites are built nearby at the company’s Redmond facility.)
Project Kuiper’s first production-quality satellites are due to be launched early next year, with beta service to begin in the latter half of 2024. At least half of Project Kuiper’s planned 3,236-satellite constellation will have to be placed in low Earth orbit by mid-2026 to comply with the terms of Amazon’s license from the Federal Communications Commission. But the vast majority of launches that Amazon has reserved would use three types of rockets that haven’t yet flown a single mission: Blue Origin’s New Glenn, ULA’s Vulcan and Arianespace’s Ariane 6.
In addition to the three newly reserved Falcon 9 launches, Amazon has slots set aside on eight Atlas V rockets — a tried-and-true product line that is reaching its final days. So even though SpaceX and Amazon could be considered satellite network rivals, and even though SpaceX founder Elon Musk and Amazon founder Jeff Bezos haven’t always been on the best of terms, the Falcon 9 reservations represent something of an insurance policy for Amazon’s deployment schedule.
The fact that SpaceX has been chosen for some of the Project Kuiper launches could also have an effect on a lawsuit complaining that Amazon didn’t give enough consideration to SpaceX when it chose its launch providers.
The Cleveland Bakers and Teamsters Pension Fund, which has Amazon stock in its portfolio, filed suit in the Delaware Court of Chancery in August. The suit alleges that Amazon’s directors and officers passed over SpaceX because of Bezos’ ownership of Blue Origin, a SpaceX rival.
“In the face of SpaceX’s proven reliability and cost advantages, Bezos-led Amazon’s decision to not even consider SpaceX as a launch provider illustrates the glaring conflict of Bezos’ affiliation with both Amazon and Blue Origin presented, and the substantial impact these conflicts had on the board’s ability to protect the best interests of the company and its stockholders in negotiating the contracts,” the pension fund said in its suit.
The fact that Amazon ended up selecting SpaceX, even for a few launches, could arguably undermine the pension fund’s argument. A hearing in the case has not yet been scheduled. Amazon says the pension fund’s claims “are completely without merit, and we look forward to showing that through the legal process.”
Warner Bros. is the studio behind «Barbie,» and it’s also the studio that Zack Snyder butted heads with over many elements of his DC Extended Universe, a clash that helped inevitably lead to the reboot of the DC film franchise under the leadership of filmmaker James Gunn. That’s why the «Snyder Cut» joke could be seen as a poke at Snyder himself.
But Snyder mentioned that Warner Bros. CEO Michael DeLuca did warn them about the jab in advance. «They gave us a heads-up,» he explained, adding that DeLuca mentioned it to his spouse and producing partner, Deborah Snyder. «‘Hey, there’s a reference to ‘Justice League’ in the movie,» Zack recalled DeLuca saying. «‘It’s cool and whatever. I hope you guys understand, we think it’s awesome.’»
Considering Zack’s response to the «Barbie» movie, it seems that he didn’t take the joke to heart. On the contrary, he appears to be blown away by how well-known he is in pop culture for this one thing. «The thing that you need to take a second and think about is that your name is so seamlessly sewed together with a pop-culture phenomenon so big it can exist as a joke in a movie about Barbie. That’s pretty insane,» he remarked, adding, «You just need to step back for a second and go like, ‘Whoa, what did we do? What happened? How is that a thing?’»